The Pupil Examination: A Practical Guide for Junior Doctors

Khashia Farooq

Introduction

The pupil examination is a quick but valuable component of both the ophthalmological and neurological examination. Abnormal pupil size or reactivity may result from benign physiological variation, but can also indicate important pathology involving the retina, optic nerve, autonomic pathways or third cranial nerve (1).

For junior doctors, the aim is not to identify every pupillary disorder, but to perform the examination systematically, recognise common patterns and identify findings requiring urgent assessment. A simple approach should consider four features: pupil size, symmetry, light responses and the presence of a relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD).

A brief reminder of the pupillary pathways

Pupillary constriction in response to light requires an intact afferent and efferent pathway (2). Light detected by the retina travels through the optic nerve and optic tract to the pretectal nuclei in the midbrain (2). Each pretectal nucleus projects bilaterally to the Edinger-Westphal nuclei, explaining why illumination of one eye normally causes constriction of both pupils (2). Parasympathetic fibres then travel with the oculomotor nerve to the ciliary ganglion and subsequently through the short ciliary nerves to the sphincter pupillae (2).

Pupillary dilatation is controlled by the sympathetic pathway (2). This is a three-neuron pathway extending from the hypothalamus, through the brainstem and cervical spinal cord, over the lung apex and into the neck before ascending alongside the internal carotid artery to reach the eye (2).

A systematic pupil examination

The pupils should ideally be examined before pharmacological dilatation. Ask the patient to look at a distant target to reduce accommodation and inspect both pupils before using a light source.

Size and symmetry

Assess whether the pupils are equal, round and regular, and estimate their size in millimetres. If anisocoria is present, compare the pupils in both bright and dim illumination.

This distinction is particularly helpful:

  • Anisocoria greater in bright light suggests that the larger pupil is abnormal, because it is not constricting normally.
  • Anisocoria greater in darkness suggests that the smaller pupil is abnormal, because it is not dilating normally.

Small, longstanding anisocoria with normal pupillary responses and no other clinical abnormalities is often physiological (3). Previous photographs can sometimes help establish whether the asymmetry is longstanding.

Direct and consensual light responses

Ask the patient to continue looking at a distant target. Shine a bright light into one eye and observe constriction of that pupil: the direct response. At the same time, the opposite pupil should also constrict: the consensual response. Repeat the process from the other side. Both pupils should normally constrict promptly regardless of which eye is illuminated.

The swinging flashlight test

The swinging flashlight test assesses for a RAPD. Illuminate one eye for approximately 2-3 seconds before moving the light briskly to the other eye, repeating this several times. In an RAPD, the affected eye provides reduced afferent input. When the light is moved from the unaffected to the affected eye, both pupils therefore constrict less and appear to dilate relative to their previous state (4).

An RAPD suggests asymmetric retinal or optic nerve dysfunction (5). Common causes include optic neuritis, ischaemic optic neuropathy, severe retinal vascular disease and markedly asymmetric glaucoma (5). Importantly, a RAPD does not cause anisocoria as the abnormality is in the afferent pathway rather than the efferent pathway controlling pupil size.

Interpreting anisocoria

Anisocoria describes unequal pupil size rather than a diagnosis itself. The clinical context and whether the asymmetry increases in light or darkness help identify the likely abnormal pupil.

  • When the larger pupil is abnormal

Anisocoria that becomes greater in bright light suggests impaired constriction of the larger pupil. Causes include third nerve palsy, Adie tonic pupil, pharmacological mydriasis and structural damage to the iris following trauma or surgery (5). Associated examination findings are important. A large pupil accompanied by ptosis and abnormal extraocular movements should immediately raise concern for a third nerve palsy (6). A painful red eye with a poorly reactive, mid-dilated pupil should instead prompt consideration of acute angle-closure glaucoma, particularly when associated with reduced vision, headache, nausea, vomiting or corneal haze (5). This requires immediate ophthalmological assessment.

  • When the smaller pupil is abnormal

Anisocoria that increases in darkness suggests impaired sympathetic dilatation of the smaller pupil. The important diagnosis to consider is Horner syndrome (7).

Third nerve palsy

The oculomotor nerve supplies most extraocular muscles, the levator palpebrae superioris and the parasympathetic pathway responsible for pupillary constriction (6). A complete third nerve palsy may therefore cause (6):

  • ptosis
  • binocular diplopia
  • impaired adduction, elevation and depression of the eye
  • a characteristic ‘down and out’ resting eye position
  • a dilated or poorly reactive pupil

Pupillary involvement is particularly concerning because the parasympathetic fibres run superficially within the third nerve and may be affected by compression, including from a posterior communicating artery aneurysm (6). Traditionally, pupil-sparing third nerve palsies were considered more likely to have a microvascular cause. However, pupil sparing does not reliably exclude an aneurysm or other compressive pathology, and contemporary recommendations support neuroimaging in acute isolated third nerve palsy (6). A new third nerve palsy therefore warrants urgent senior assessment and appropriate neuroimaging, particularly when associated with pupillary involvement, headache or pain.

Horner syndrome

Horner syndrome results from interruption of the sympathetic pathway supplying the eye. The classical findings are (7):

  • miosis
  • mild ptosis
  • ipsilateral facial anhidrosis, although this is not always apparent

The anisocoria becomes more obvious in darkness because the affected pupil fails to dilate normally. The direct and consensual light responses remain intact. The significance of Horner syndrome lies in the extensive course of the sympathetic pathway, meaning pathology can occur anywhere from the hypothalamus to the eye (2). Of particular importance, acute Horner syndrome associated with ipsilateral head, facial or neck pain should raise concern for internal carotid artery dissection and requires urgent vascular imaging (7).

Pharmacological testing with apraclonidine can support the diagnosis of Horner (7). Investigation should not, however, be delayed where the clinical presentation suggests an acute vascular cause.

Other abnormalities to recognise

An Adie tonic pupil is typically enlarged and reacts poorly to light but better to near fixation (5). It is usually benign once other important causes of a new abnormal pupil have been excluded.

Pharmacological mydriasis may follow exposure to anticholinergic or sympathomimetic drugs, including ophthalmic dilating drops. Normal eyelid position and extraocular movements make a third nerve palsy less likely, but a medication or exposure history should not replace neurological assessment where red flags are present.

Previous ocular surgery or trauma can also produce a permanently enlarged or irregular pupil due to structural iris damage. Comparing with previous documentation can be useful.

When should the pupil examination prompt urgent referral?

For junior doctors, several combinations should immediately raise concern:

  1. Dilated pupil + ptosis + ophthalmoplegia:
    Consider an acute third nerve palsy and intracranial aneurysm.
  2. Small pupil + mild ptosis + acute head or neck pain:
    Consider Horner syndrome secondary to carotid artery dissection.
  3. RAPD + acute visual loss:
    Consider significant optic nerve or retinal disease.
  4. Mid-dilated poorly reactive pupil + painful red eye:
    Consider acute angle-closure glaucoma.
  5. New anisocoria + reduced consciousness or focal neurological signs:
    Consider acute intracranial pathology and escalate immediately.

The pupil examination should always be interpreted alongside visual acuity, ocular movements, neurological findings and the patient’s symptoms.

Documenting the examination

Documentation should be specific rather than simply recording ‘pupils normal’ or ‘PEARL’.

For example: ‘Pupils equal at 3 mm, round and briskly reactive to light bilaterally. No RAPD.’

Where anisocoria is present, document pupil size in light and darkness and any associated ptosis or ocular motility abnormality.Accurate documentation is particularly useful when repeated examinations are required to identify clinical change.

Conclusion

A reliable pupil examination requires only a light source and a systematic approach. Assess size and symmetry, compare anisocoria in light and darkness, test the direct and consensual responses, and perform a swinging flashlight test for RAPD.

The most important skill is not recognising every pupillary syndrome, but identifying patterns that may indicate serious disease. A new third nerve palsy, painful Horner syndrome, RAPD with acute visual loss or a mid-dilated pupil in a painful red eye should prompt urgent investigation or specialist assessment.

References

1. Lisowski Ł, Lisowska J, Charytonowicz A, Mariak Z, Obuchowska I, Konopińska J. The diagnostic significance of pupillary reflex pathways: insights from classical examination and advanced pupillometry. Frontiers in Neuroscience. 2025;19:1677431. doi:10.3389/fnins.2025.1677431

2. Wilhelm H, Kardon RH. The pupillary light reflex pathway. Neuro-Ophthalmology. 1997;17(2):59-62. doi:10.3109/01658109709044647

3. Lam BL, Thompson HS, Corbett JJ. The prevalence of simple nisocoria. Am J  Ophthalmol. 1987;104(1):69-73. doi:10.1016/0002-9394(87)90296-0

4. Broadway DC. How to test for a relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD). Community Eye Health. 2012;25(79-80):58. Accessed 28 October 2026. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3588138/

5. Kawasaki AK. Diagnostic Approach to Pupillary Abnormalities. Continuum (Minneap Minn). 2014;20(4):1008-1022. doi:10.1212/01.con.0000453306.42981.94

6. Patel RD, Burdon MA. Isolated third cranial nerve palsies-modern management principles. Eye (Lond). 2022;36(1):232-3. doi:10.1038/s41433-020-01349-1.

7. Davagnanam I, Fraser CL, Miszkiel K, Daniel CS, Plant GT. Adult Horner’s syndrome: a combined clinical, pharmacological, and imaging algorithm. Eye (Lond). 2013;27(3):291-8. doi:10.1038/eye.2012.281.

Leave a Reply